This is one of the hardest questions to answer.
Why?
Because there is no single, easy answer.
Ideally, I would have a big pool of billheads(receipts), an assortment of ledgers from many different milliners, and a few dozen diary entries to create a database of prices based on year, region, area, time of year, type of piece, etc..
Then, I would feel like I had a hint of an answer.
But, I don’t have that. I don’t think anyone has that.
Bonnets varied in materials. Even when looking at straw bonnets, there was a vast variety of quality. Then came trims. The ribbons, feathers, flowers, bobbinette, lace, etc all varied in price. Year, season, and location were all factors.
For years, I saved every 19th century bill/receipt that came up for sale. I have purchased several within a particular focus and my budget. I have a collection of wholesale billheads for every purchase a smaller milliner made for a year.
Even with this slowly developing pool, it is impossible to answer “a bonnet cost __this___ much.”
A single billhead can show the price of items from particular stores in a particular region in a particular year. When billheads are gathered together, for a milliner, for a region, for a year, a picture begins to develop.
Sometimes (a rare accurace) a single billhead can give us a little more. This bill from 1849 lists several items purchased.
One trimmed bonnet cost $4.50 in May. A pink silk bonnet cost $3.50 in December. Two bonnets and trimmings “last spring” cost $6.35. (This bill also tells us the products and services this shop in Springfield provides, the frequency in which this family of an unknown number of women purchases bonnets, and the delay in payment from “last spring” to April, 1849 for this bill to January, 1850 for the payment.)
….
Diary entries like these from Caroline Richards of Canandaigua, NY give us a look at the prices she paid for her millinery:
Wednesday, 1854 – Ann Eliza is going down street with us this afternoon to buy us some new summer bonnets;. They are to be trimmed with blue and white and are to come to five dollars. We are going to Mr Stannard’s store also, to buy us some stockings.
April 12, 1856 — We went down town this morning and bought us some shaker bonnets; to wear to school. They cost $1 apiece and we got some green silk for capes to put on them. We fixed them ourselves and wore them to school and some of the girls liked them and some did not, but it makes no difference to me what they like, for I shall wear mine till it is worn out. …
Saturday, 1854 – We got our new summer hats; from Mrs Freshour’s millinery and we wore them over to show to Aunt Ann and she said they were the very handsomest bonnets she had seen this year.
If I have to give a price, I can give a window for the mid century of as low as $1 for Shaker bonnets for school to $4.50 for a decorated silk bonnet. But, my answer has holes in that these examples span two different geographic regions and come from two different size cities.
Do you enjoy reading my blog? Do you find it helpful? Please consider supporting through Patreon or Sending a Tip.























































