Working Attire Survey Results

I had planned on developing a full article on working support garments. But, I have been utterly swamped (yes after being bored) with a new home style, two major projects, and a new job. So, rather than have the information from the survey just sit around, I am posting it. I ended up with exactly 100 respondants. I had hoped for double that to get a good sample. 100 isn’t bad though. I need to figure out how to properly post the 123 comments people took the time to make in the survey. There are a variety of different views and reasonings in them. This was just the look at how this is interpreted by the living history community. The other, and larger, componant of the original article plan was a look at what literature and photographic evidence tells us about what women worn in different work situations. I will try to get some of that information up over the next several weeks as well.

Question 1. What undergarment do you wear while doing light domestic work such as preparing food, washing dishes or sweeping?

Corset wtih full boning – 83.8%
Corset with light boning – 10.1%        
                          10.3% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Stays with soft or light boning – 4%      
                                   4.1% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Nothing 0%   
Modern Bra – 4%   

                                   4.1% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Do not do this activity – 2%
1 skipped this question

Question 2. What undergarment do you wear while doing heavy domestic work such as cooking in a hearth, on a stove or over a fire or doing laundry?

Corset wtih full boning –  61.6%     

                                   79.2% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Corset with light boning –  11.1%          
                       14.3 % (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Stays with soft or light boning – 7.1%         
                          9.1% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Nothing – 0%          
Modern Bra – 4%            
                            5.2% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Do not do this activity – 22.2%
1 skipped this question
 

Question 3. What undergarments do you wear while doing moderate outside work such as collecting firewood or gardening?

Corset wtih full boning –  66.3%   
                                                     79.3% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Corset with light boning –  10.2%  
                                                    8.5% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Stays with soft or light boning 6.1- %           
                                                       7.3% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Nothing – 0%
Modern Bra – 6.1%           
                              7.3% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Do not do this activity – 16.3%
2 skipped this question
 

 Question 4. What undergarment do you wear while doing heavier agricultural work such as farming or building?

Corset wtih full boning –  25.3%           
                                64.1% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Corset with light boning –  8.1%             
                                    20.5% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Stays with soft or light boning – 5.1%            
                                      12.8% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Nothing – 1%            
                                             2.6% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Modern Bra – 4%           
                            10.3% (excluding those who do not do this activity)
Do not do this activity – 60.6%
1 skipped this question

Question 5. Is your corset

Custom made in person or by yourself – 58.3%
Custom made by measurements – 31.3%
Authentically made off the rack – 12.5%
Acceptably made off the rack – 1%
Something that gets by – 1%
4 skipped this question
Question 6. How would you describe the fit of your corset?
Comfortable fit with no complaints – 68.0%
Right shape for me but a little loose – 4.1%
Right shape for me but a little tight – 5.2%
Roughly a good fit with some issues to fix – 21.6%
Will do now until I replace it – 7.2%
3 people skipped this question
Question 7. Does the fit of your corset affect when/if you wear it?
Yes – 28.9%
No – 73.2%
3 skipped this question
Question 8. Does your body type, bust size and/or figure affect when/if you wear a corset?
Yes – 24.7%
No – 75.3%
3 skipped this question
Question 9. Does the weather (heat, humidity, rain) affect when/if you wear a corset?
Yes –  15.5%
No – 84.5%
3 skipped this question
Question 10. Do you think mid-19th century women wore a support garment (corset or stays) while doing work?
Yes – 92.9%
No – 3.1%
Don’t know 5.1%
2 skipped this question

 

Published in: on August 28, 2009 at 7:36 pm  Leave a Comment  

One Question Survey for Upcoming Ribbon Presentation

I am working on an upcoming presentation on Mid-Century Ribbons used for Millinery. I am trying to decide how much time to give each sub-topic. Please take a look at this one question survey….

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s.aspx?sm=O3honG_2fR6zlfGh4GVNkZng_3d_3d

Published in: on August 7, 2009 at 3:04 pm  Leave a Comment  

The Philosophy of Head-dresses

Graham’s American Monthly Magazine of Literature, Art, and Fashion – August 1855

Head coverings, both for man and woman, naturally—or rather, historically, divide themselves into three classes: First, the simple bonnet, or the Phrygian cap of liberty, free-and-easy, and in all ages made symbolical of a state of rude political freedom; second, the turban, or mysterious bonnet, composed of innumerable complicated folds. It is a long serpent of muslin, wound round the head. Third, the hat, the head costume of the men, of what is called, vaguely enough, the “civilized world.” The hat is the emblem of practicality, gravity, and decorum. Judgment belongs to the North. The Chinese wear the hat, but they have it peaked at the top like a sugar-loaf—an emblem of folly and gravity combined. The Quakers have adopted the very gravest form of the hat—low-crowned and broad-brimmed. It is in perfect consonance with their assumed character. Were a Quaker to raise the crown of his hat, like the chevalier of the seventeenth century, he would look more like Wamba, the son of Witless, than like a follower of the grave, the venerable and thoughtful George Fox; and were ho to clip off a portion of the projecting eaves, the world would perceive at once, perhaps without knowing why, that he was giving way to the temptations of the flesh, and restating the spirit of non-conformity, that gives inspiration to his brethren.

As there are different characters for hats, so also are there for bonnets. Some are emblematical of liberty, others of subjection; but even the latter involve the idea of a state of social disorder. The turban is mystery personified; and all who wear it, whether male or female, are involved in its tortuous folds. The monks used to wear skull-caps; so did the Reformers, Luther, Calvin, and others. It was the ecclesiastical fashion of the day. The skull-cap in a very close fit. It is impossible for an ago to be very free in its genius, with such a cap. It is too exclusive. It acts like a censorship on the press. Those who wear it are stern and powerful, but conscientious, bigots. Poets eschew the skull-cap; they prefer even the fools-cap or night-cap. Pope and Cowper are generally represented in these. They give, at least, scope to genius. But as they do not stand erect, they tend to nourish moroseness, melancholy, and bad humor

Women’s caps and hats are not so easily classed as those of men; but the general law is applicable to them also. The cap without a rim is the widow’s cap, because she is then free. So long as a woman’s husband is alive, as the Apostle says, she is under the law of her husband; but when the husband is dead, she is free from that law, and therefore, she wears a cap without a rim, as the proper widow’s cap is. But the widows are gradually infringing on the old law, like the Quakeresses, and conforming more and more to the gay fashion of the day. The border or rim belongs appropriately to the cap of the discreet matron ; the turban to the mysterious intriguants,  whose ways are as cunning as those of a serpent on a rock—one of the four things which Solomon could not understand.

A small bonnet, for a lady, is an emblem of gayety and liberty. She can, in such a bonnet, see with the corners of her eyes, and survey the whole semicircle of which her nose is the centre. But in a Quakeress’ bonnet, she can only see beyond her nose, and a few degrees on each side of it. If a gentleman should look at her from the opposite side of the street, she observeth him not. Even if a horse should make a snap at her arm, as she passeth along the pavement, she doth not perceive it. (And that this is a matter of serious consideration, is demonstrated from the fact that, a few years ago, a young lady’s cheek was bitten off by a horse which was standing close to the sidewalk of a crowded thoroughfare.) A woman in such a bonnet, is imprisoned in a coal- scuttle, contrived on purpose both to elude and prevent observation.

But, with the modern gay little bonnet, hung upon the back hair, the forehead all exposed, and the eyes at full liberty to describe the whole field of vision, a lady is made up for conjugating the verb to tee, active and passive voice, in all Its moods, tenses, and persons. This gay bonnet forebodes the same revolutionary, anarchical proceedings in the domestic sphere, which the bonnet rouge foreshadowed in the political world.

 

Nothing so quiet, and sober, and maturely-looking for a woman, as a large Leghorn, that ties round the chin, and hangs down the back like a coal-heaver’s hat, or rolls up behind like a parson’s shovel—not cocking up as if the face were behind, in the Nell Gwynn style. A woman so attired, is sure to be discreet, modest, subject, timorous, apt to scream, very much afraid of all strange people, and well armed with jealousy and suspicion of all evil-looking persons, such as foreigners (or natives either) with drab-colored moustaches hanging over their mouths, or gentlemen whose shirt-bosoms are not visible, but whose manners, notwithstanding, affect those of the court or stage, or something very different from ordinary life. Such a woman is an affectionate wife, a fond mother, an excellent economist, and a severe critic of all irregular living, at home or abroad. Such ladies, we fear, have of late years been rapidly going out of fashion—all owing to the small, flaring bonnet, which, from being so easily put on and carried about, makes them sad gad-abouts and gossips. But, to all these coverings for the head, certainly the one combining at once grace and modesty, destined at once to embellish and conceal, is the veil. The veil, which has gone entirely out of fashion in the most civilized countries, those in which fashions are the most studied, has been retained by the cloistered nun,” whom we never see, and by the bride, who wears it of such transparent and flimsy texture that it actually conceals less than the most expansive of bonnets.

Veils are still worn in Italy and Spain. The Empress Eugenie, in virtue of her Spanish associations, tried to introduce the black mantilla into France, but its sombre hue and monotonous folds were unsuited to French taste, and met with most violent opposition not only from the fair devotees of fashion but from a whole population of florist- feather cullers, ribbon makers, frame makers and milliners—finish a host docs it take to manufacture the modern bonnet— against which the small shot of philosophy appears specially to be directed; but in a utilitarian age, where the cry is employment and encouragement to the working classes, the bonnet actually turns out to be quite a philanthropic institution, one not to be sneered at, but to be both praised and encouraged

Published in: on August 7, 2009 at 1:02 am  Leave a Comment